|
Question: The Company requires a new employee to hand over the original university degree and pay a deposit of VND 5,000,000 to ensure the employee works for at least 12 months. If the employee leaves early, the Company will keep the deposit and retain the original degree. Is this practice lawful? How should the Company protect its interests?
Answer: This practice is not lawful. Article 17 of the 2019 Labor Code prohibits employers from doing so when entering into and performing labor contracts. 1. Prohibitions under Article 17 of the 2019 Labor Code • Retaining the employee’s original identity documents, degrees or certificates (clause 1). • Requiring the employee to provide a security in the form of money or other assets for the performance of the labor contract (clause 2). Accordingly, requiring the original university degree and a VND 5,000,000 deposit are both violations. The employee’s consent does not make the practice lawful. 2. Legal consequences for the enterprise The Company may be subject to administrative penalties in the labor field under current regulations, namely Decree No. 283/2026/ND-CP, effective 10 September 2026 (replacing Decree No. 12/2022/ND-CP). In addition, the Company must return the documents and any money held, and may have to compensate the employee if retaining the documents causes loss. 3. Lawful ways to protect the Company’s interests Instead of retaining originals or collecting deposits, the Company should: 1. Keep copies only; if verification is needed, check the originals when receiving the file and return them to the employee immediately. 2. Set out rights, obligations and minimum service commitments clearly in the labor contract and internal labor regulations, and handle breaches under the rules on labor discipline and material liability. 3. For employees trained at the Company’s expense, sign a training contract and a reimbursement agreement covering properly documented training costs under Articles 61 and 62 of the 2019 Labor Code. 4. If documents or deposits are already held, return them to the employee immediately and record the handover in minutes. Conclusion Employers may not retain an employee’s original degrees or identity documents, or collect deposits. To protect its interests, the Company should rely on lawful tools such as contractual commitments, internal labor regulations and training-cost reimbursement agreements, and should promptly review and remedy any existing cases of retained documents or deposits. If your business needs detailed advice on this matter, please contact SB Law for timely support from our team of lawyers and experts. |

What regulations and procedures should foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) pay attention to when recruiting and employing Vietnamese workers in Vietnam? Question: We are a foreign-invested organization


